Volume & Issue: Volume 4, Issue 2 - Serial Number 8, October 2025, Pages 1-292 
Editor-in-Chief Lecture Codicology

Content production with old manuscripts

Pages 1-4

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.229052

Zohair Tayyeb

Abstract Producing and supplying content in cyberspace is as essential as breathing for the actors in this field. Today, in every aspect of human life, there are faces and players who make sports, music, cinema, lifestyle, travel, cooking, technology, industry, the inner aspects of humans, and similar topics the subject of content provision and attracting a general audience. Content supply companies professionally launch and manage various channels, and individuals and specialists in each field also utilize the capabilities of cyberspace to present their personal channels for public viewing and approval.
Manuscripts and ancient documents are a rich source and a flowing spring for activists and enthusiasts in this cultural and artistic domain to focus on, produce, and supply content about them. This way, they take on a cultural and historical mission and also test their abilities in attracting audiences in a fresh, novel, and less explored area. The general positive approach to this field, people's interest in manuscripts, the mysterious nature and exploratory essence of this scientific research area align with the elements of the digital economy and entertainment and correspond to the business model of supplying virtual content.
Meanwhile, attention to some points is necessary for enthusiasts and actors in this field:
1. Be aware of the challenges of this field before entering and plan for them: Access to manuscripts and manuscript repositories usually requires initial coordination. So, before starting, consider this important factor and allocate time and program planning for it.
2. Compensate for weak storytelling: Accuracy and attractiveness are two important pillars of content that can be produced in this field. Use an efficient and experienced scientific advisor and do not act recklessly. In an environment where some researchers also fall into the trap of research errors, the task of content creators who produce content in this field without sufficient experience, expertise, and scientific advisors is clear. Please do not introduce incorrect data into public culture.  
3. Offer universally appealing form and content: Create story-driven and visual content. Utilize diverse formats such as short podcasts, infographics, and the like. Place yourself in historical contexts close to the subject and strive for temporal and spatial alignment.  
4. Have a thematic list of selected manuscripts: This helps you produce attractive and relevant content according to events and stay connected with your audience community.  
5. Find your material and spiritual cultural supporters: Libraries, institutions, and cultural centers have budgets for their presence and presentation in the virtual arena. Establish active communication with public relations and do not overlook other commercial and culture-loving supporters.  
6. Observe scientific and media ethics: Manuscript content is unfiltered. You must choose which topics are ethical and appropriate to present in the public sphere and which issues should not be published. Adopt self-monitoring as your model.  
7. Before starting, look at inspiring examples: Benefit from them but do not rely solely on them; move forward.

@Getty Museum Manuscripts (YouTube)
@manuscriptsetc (Instagram)
@SexycodicologyNet (YouTube)
@Spanish Antiphoner: Codicology and Paleography (YouTube)
@teachingcodex (Instagram)
@The ABCs of Codicology: Describing Manuscripts for Beginners (YouTube)
@uofgcodicologist (Instagram)
@visions_of_manuscripts (Instagram)

Original Article Textology

A comparative Comparison of Heydari's History by Hosseini Razi with Tatavi's Alfi History

Pages 5-21

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2024.433685.1130

Seyedhossein Hosseiniseddiq, Elham Malekzadeh

Abstract Heydari's history is one of the historical texts of the Safavid era, which was written by Mir Heydar -ibn Ali -ibn Mahmoud Hosseini Razi, one of the authors and historians of the first half of the 11th century AH. The manuscript Majma al-Tawarikh or Zubda al-Tawarikh or Heydari's history is a general and irregularly authored history of the history of Iran and the Seljuk’s of Minor Asia, the Khans of Karim, the Ottomans, and the Muslim kings of India. This work includes five chapters. These five chapters make up the first volume, which is related to prophets, caliphs, and kings, and the second volume should be on "sages, scholars, and poets." The sources used by Heydari's history, which he also mentioned in the introduction, are many; One of these sources is the history of Alfi belong to Qazi Ahmad Tatawi.
In this research, while introducing the author and the manuscript of Heydari's history, using the comparative-analytical method, it is attempted to examine the historiography and compare the two works of Heydari's history and Tatawi's Alfi history, and identify the possible differences and shortcomings of the two works. The result of this research shows that the author of Heydari's history has taken the major part of his book from Alfi history. The most important reason for the difference between these two works should be found in the historiographic goals of these two authors.

Original Article Textology

The codicology of the oldest Quranic interpretation, Al Basāer Fi Vojooh Va AlNazāer

Pages 22-52

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.488869.1169

Rahimeh Babrekateh shamshiri, milad Jafarpoor

Abstract "Al-Basa'ir fi al-Wujuh wa al-Naza'ir" is the title of a Persian work authored by Abu al-Fadail Muhammad ibn Husayn Ma'ini (d. 537 AH), which addresses the discussions of Quranic sciences, particularly the topic of "wujuh" (various meanings) and "naza'ir" (analogies). In this research, conducted through library study and using a descriptive-analytical method, alongside a detailed introduction of "Al-Basa'ir" and its manuscripts, the characteristics, orthography, and stylistic details of the oldest copy of "Al-Basa'ir" are also reported. Additionally, some leniencies related to the introduction of this source and its author have been critiqued and examined. The purpose of introducing "Al-Basa'ir" and its manuscripts, as a significant reference in the field of lexicology and Quranic exegesis, is to express the necessity of reviving this written heritage of the Persian language, whose breadth of information surpasses that of earlier works on the same subject.

Original Article Textology

Introduction of the Manuscript Golestan-e- Eram, A Newly Discovered Narrative of the story of Seyf al-Molook and Badi' al-Jamal

Pages 53-77

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.489897.1171

katayoon Baharlooie, Mahbouba , Khorasani, Mehrdad Chatraei Azizabadi, morteza rashidi

Abstract Abstract
Gulestan-e- Eram is a narrative of the story of Seyf al-Molook and Badi' al-Jamal which has written in the 11th century. This study introduce this work, its most important stylistic features, and compare it with this story in One Thousand and One Nights and One Thousand and One Days. The results show this story was written before the Henryeh version. The similarity in the beginning and ending style and the shared majority of the story events of Gulestan-e- Eram with the One Thousand and One Nights narrative, and its minimal alignment with the same story in One Thousand and One Days, increases the likelihood that Seyf al-Molook and Badi' al-Jamal in One Thousand and One Nights was rewritten from Gulestan-e Eram. Additionally, the use of archaic language, specific grammatical structures, and the abundance of literary devices such as similes, metaphors, personifications, descriptions, hyperboles, metonymy, attributes arrangement, proverbs, and citations of poems place this work in the realm of intermediate prose. Most of the allusions in this work are verbal, the similes are elaborate, and the metaphors are explicit. Additionally, the inclusion of 274 couplets and 6 hemistichs in this work demonstrates the author’s command over poetry collections. Poems by Saadi, Jami, Helali , Amir Khosro Dehlavi, Hafez, Nezami, Ibn-e-Emad Shirazi, Rumi, and Khajoo Kermani have the highest frequencies in the text. the author reflects many of the cultural, political, and social beliefs prevalent in the courts of Ghaznavi and Egypt, in addition to expressing their religious beliefs.

Original Article Textology

Textology of the Dastoor Al-Insha (Sahayef al-Latayef) of Samarqandi

Pages 78-106

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.480802.1163

seyyed amir jahadi hoseyni

Abstract Among the advanced sources that have not been known and examined so far, it should be mentioned Dastoor Alinsha or Sahaif-ul-Lataif Abdul Razzaq Samarqandi. Samarqandi is one of the historians, secretaries and nobles of Shahrukh's court in the Timurid era, and the work of the respected Matla e Saadin on the history of that era is one of his works. His works have many values in terms of old writing and essay styles as well as prose style and historical information. In this article, which has been done using qualitative content analysis and description, the writer intends to examine and evaluate the content and structure of the work from the perspective of textology. The findings of the research show that the origins of Samarqandi consist of two separate and distinct parts. The first part, which is called the Dastoor Alinsha, presents and explains the theoretical foundations and principles of court writing and transmission in a detailed plan. In this section, the characteristics of speech in terms of delivery and rhetoric have been examined. Also, the characteristics of the scribe and the textual structures of the manuscripts and some customs related to writing, calligraphy and paper are also discussed. In the second part, Samarqandi, by quoting samples of Diwani and Soltani's letters, has shown both the art of secretarial writing and has drawn practical models for the secretaries and the audience.

Original Article Textology

The Authenticity of the Single Complete Printed Version of the Haqiq al-Tafseer from the Fatih Manuscript Based on Manuscripts: A Critical Review

Pages 107-131

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.485200.1165

mozhgan sarshar, mahdi mehrizi, masome rafiei

Abstract The present article seeks to examine the credibility of the sole printed edition of the book "Haqqaiq al-Tafsir" and its correspondence with manuscript versions. This book, regarded as one of the most significant interpretative writings with a Sufi and esoteric approach, has always attracted special attention from scholars due to this perspective and the important and great personality of its author, Abdul Rahman Solami. The inclusion of approximately 360 narrations from Ja'far ibn Muhammad has further heightened interest in this book. Today, there is only one printed version of this book available, which serves as the basis for many studies regarding its content. This edition was published by Sayyid Imran in the year 1421 AH. This version has been compared with the manuscript used by Sayyid Imran as well as other manuscripts. The findings from this comparison, obtained through a descriptive, analytical method and with a critical approach, indicate that this sole printed edition of "Haqqaiq" is by no means reliable and does not exempt researchers from referring to the original manuscripts of the book. The issues identified in the manuscript, such as numerous significant omissions, literary errors, and inaccuracies in transcription, as well as mistakes made by the researcher in reading the manuscript that led to the omission of the text, along with carelessness in extracting content from the manuscript, are among such issues.

Original Article Textology

Recognition of the distorted word "Barkham"

Pages 132-146

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.488589.1168

jamile akhyani

Abstract One of the points that must be taken into account by correctors in correcting ancient texts is the possibility of correcting a word or words from the text. Failure to pay attention to this point, in addition to moving the text away from its exact meaning, can cause the forgetting of an original word. One of these words, which was spelled due to the tradition of same writing of some of letters such as "P" and "B" in Persian manuscripts, and then was forgotten over time and with the scribes copying each other's manuscripts, is the word "Barkham". This word, which is used in a significant number of important texts of Persian literature such as Sanai's Divan, Anvari's Divan, Kamal Khojandi's Divan, Zahir Faryabi's Divan and Saeb's Divan, is recorded everywhere as "Porkham" and has not entered Persian dictionaries. In this article, we will recover this word and its difference with "Porkham" which is spelled with it with a descriptive-analytical method and based on documentary studies. Based on this, the word "Barkham" is another form of "Bekham" and means "bent". In addition, this article also discusses the two words "barbar" and " barbar " that are recorded in a corrected form in some texts.

Original Article Text Correction

Analytical understanding and introduction of the manuscript of the grammatical poem of Seyyed Alinaghi Hosseini Dashti

Pages 147-174

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.502951.1182

HOSSEIN MOHTADI, Azra Sadat Latifi Hosseini

Abstract The Syntactic System of Sayyid Alinaghi Hosseini Dashti, a magnificent and unpublished work from the 13th century AH, is one of the most prominent scientific works in the field of the rules of Arabic grammar, composed in a poetic order and in the meter of Al-Fiyah of Ibn Malik Al-Andalus. The present research is descriptive-analytical and is based on the study of existing manuscripts and the analysis of its content. The article first briefly introduces the life, works, and scientific position of Sayyid Alinaghi Hosseini Dashti; then it examines the stylistic and structural features of the system. The research findings show that this work is included in 47 syntactic chapters in a systematic and structured manner in the form of 736 verses. This work, utilizing linguistic eloquence: literary devices such as simile and metaphor, and novel syntactic combinations, is a unique example in the tradition of scientific verse literature. Unlike other educational poetry collections such as "Al-Fiyah Ibn Malik" that focus more on syntactic and educational aspects, Al-Fiyah of Sayyid Alinaghi Dashti is not only an educational source; it is also an inspiring model for Arabic educational literature that has been able to convey syntactic concepts along with moral and spiritual values ​​to the audience in a novel way. In addition to its educational value, this poetry collection is considered a document for studying the scientific and cultural history of the Dashti region of Bushehr province.

Original Article Codicology

Analyzing the influence of Shiite Sufism in the semantic and structural reading of the passage of Siavash from fire from the Shahnameh of Shah Ismail II in Qazvin School

Pages 175-214

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2024.446558.1140

Elaheh Panjehbashi, Matineh Asadollahi

Abstract In the Safavid period, with the connection between Sufism and Shiism, art, works with religious and mythological themes can be seen. In the following article, the painting Siavash passing through the fire, from, the manuscript of the Shahnameh of Shah Ismail II in 984 A.H. is examined; This painting contains many layers of meaning. The purpose of reading this painting is to investigate the mystical and religious concepts of the Safavid period and reflect it in this painting. How has the combination of the structure of the image been influenced by Shiite mysticism in reaching this meaning? How does the painting show mystical effects? This research was done by descriptive-analytical method and it is of qualitative research type and it was done using library resources. The picture of the painting was obtained by the authors from the archive of Reza Abbasi Museum in Tehran. The results of this research show that it has mythological and symbolic concepts, which conveys mystical and Shiite meaning to the audience with multiple figures and the use of diverse compositions. The composition of the work is circular and ascending and refers to the meanings of transcendental mysticism and spiritual ascension. The attention of the political government in the Safavid period to Shiism along with Sufism and the combination of the two has resulted in the creation of a painting with a beautiful composition and bright colors with hidden religious themes, which is rare in its kind and has not been the subject of independent research.

Original Article Text Correction

Manuscriptology of Tazkirat al-Abrar

Pages 215-243

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.469965.1154

Hossein Ibnali chermahini, Esmaeil Tajbakhsh, Mahmoud Bashiri

Abstract Abstract
Through the study of a work's manuscripts, it becomes possible to carry out precise editing, comprehensive analysis, and to fill the gaps in the knowledge of manuscript studies. Tazkirat al-Abrar is a work with mystical themes, describing the lives of Sufi Sayyids in the Indian subcontinent who were initiated into various Sufi orders. Some of the prominent figures among them also served in military and governmental affairs. This book is largely unknown to most scholars and has not been introduced or published elsewhere. The purpose of this article is to identify the manuscripts of Tazkirat al-Abrar, clarify the ambiguity surrounding its true author, and ultimately examine the stylistic features of the manuscript housed at the Malek National Library in Tehran. This theoretical study uses a descriptive-analytical method to collect, compare, and draw final conclusions on the subject. Linguistically, the dominant style of the Mughal period is evident in the frequent use of compound adjectives, participial forms, equivalent adjective-noun pairs, weak sentence structures, Indian and Gujarati vocabulary, Persian words commonly used in the subcontinent, and unconventional plural forms such as Afaghina (Afghans) in this tazkira (biographical compendium). From a content perspective, the use of miraculous acts attributed to the sheikhs, followed by discussions on sainthood in Sufism, Welayah, Tawhid, knowledge of the divine, and the significance of the kherqa (successorship cloak), are more frequent.

Original Article Text Correction

The necessity of correcting the manuscript of "Aql e Bidar" by Sultan Bahu

Pages 244-263

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.489264.1170

Ata ul Kareem, Ali reza mastali parsa, Uzma Zareen Nazia

Abstract Hazrat Sultan Bahoo is one of the great religious and mystical scholars and one of the prominent writers and poets of Arabic, Persian and Punjabi languages. He has written 140 books in the field of Sufism and mysticism, which includes one book in Punjabi language and 139 other books in Persian language, including prose and a divan of poetry. Bahoo- founder of the Qadiriyya famil- whatever he said and whatever he wrote against his contemporaries, the people accepted it with open heart and mostly became his disciples. So his words have a deep impact on people.
The title of this research is “The necessity of correcting the manuscript of "Aql e Bidar" by Sultan Bahu". The book Aql e Bidar is a manuscript whose date of authorship is unknown, but it is often believed that it was written during the reign of King Aurangzeb Alamgir. The mysteries of the names of ALLAH (Attributes), the interpretation of Faqr(فقر) and the rank of Faqr, the Role and Importance of Hoo(هُو), the goals and objectives of the chain of Qadiriya, and the details and assessment of evil scholars are mentioned in this book.
His writings have been translated in many languages and are taught across the world. He holds a distinguished and celebrated position among all-time great Punjabi Sufi poets and his poetry always remained popular among academics as well as common people alike.

Original Article Text Correction

Theory of Contextual Correction and Its Applications

Pages 264-292

https://doi.org/10.22034/crtc.2025.528536.1193

Zohair Tayyeb, Ibrahim Eghbal

Abstract "Contextual correction" is a method applicable in the correction of ancient texts (manuscripts). This method, alongside other conventional methods such as foundational correction (news-based), comparative (grammatical), selective (jurisprudential), and their integration, can be beneficial and possesses the necessary efficiency. This fundamental research, conducted in a library-based manner with a qualitative approach, identifies and examines "contextual correction" as an effective and efficient method, and explores "context" and its role in the accurate reading of historical texts in the direction of developing text correction theory. This research indicates that mastery over the context of the text leads to the identification of damages, resolution of inadequacies and problems, improvement and reconstruction of errors and omissions, and revitalization of the text. Historical naming (following in the footsteps of predecessors), logical and scientific definition, methodological validity and efficiency, and clarification of ambiguous concepts and texts considering the context of the text are among the advantages of contextual correction. In contextual correction, attention is paid to linguistic types, and the historical grammar of the language is the researcher's criterion. Additionally, besides the general style of the period under study, the specific style of the author in their other works is also examined and read. Thus, "contextual correction" as an innovative and effective method provides researchers and literary correctors with a new capability for the accurate reading and reconstruction of historical texts.